The judging criterion for EB-1A and O-1A: evaluating the work of peers
What counts as judging for a talent visa case, which roles may qualify and how to document your participation in evaluating other professionals.
Could this visa fit your profile? Answer a few questions for a free case review.
Review my case →What the criterion says
EB-1A and O-1A include a criterion for judging the work of others in your field or an allied field, individually or on a panel. It concerns actual evaluation of other professionals' work.
Which roles may qualify
- serving on a jury for professional competitions or awards;
- peer reviewing for scholarly or professional journals;
- serving on a conference programme committee;
- evaluating grants, startup programmes or hackathons;
- mentoring or evaluating within professional accelerators, where actual judging is documented.
What the officer considers
- Field. The work you evaluate should relate to your profession or an allied field.
- Standing. The standing of the competition or publication can affect the weight of the evidence.
- Invitation. Show that you were invited for your expertise, rather than merely signing up.
- Documents. Independent confirmation of your role is needed, such as organiser letters, public pages or certificates.
Common problems
- the role is described generally, without identifying the work evaluated;
- there is no confirmation from the organiser;
- the event has limited standing or is unrelated to your profession;
- the case does not explain why the competition or publication matters.
How to strengthen this evidence
Identify professional events and publications that need qualified evaluators, prepare a profile supported by evidence of your expertise, and document your actual participation. We help assess relevant opportunities and organise case materials.
Frequently asked questions
Can reviewing a single piece of work count?
It may, but repeated participation and evidence that you were selected for your expertise can strengthen the record. The work should be in your field or an allied field.
What documents show judging activity?
Invitations, organiser letters, certificates, event programmes, jury pages on organisers' websites, confirmation of your role and a description of the work you evaluated.
Need help with your case?
We review your achievements, identify strengths and gaps against the criteria, and suggest a plan. We work alongside your attorney.
→Request a consultation