What USCIS considers in an EB-1A case: the two-step assessment and final merits determination
How USCIS assesses an EB-1A petition: initial evidence followed by an overall assessment of achievements. What matters at each stage.
Could this visa fit your profile? Answer a few questions for a free case review.
Review my case →The two-step assessment
EB-1A adjudication uses a two-step approach reflected in decisions such as Kazarian v. USCIS and in USCIS policy guidance.
- Initial evidentiary requirements. The officer checks for a qualifying major, internationally recognised award or evidence satisfying at least 3 of the 10 criteria.
- Final merits determination. After the initial evidentiary requirements are met, the officer considers the record as a whole to assess sustained national or international acclaim and whether the applicant is among the small percentage at the very top of the field.
Why meeting initial criteria is not enough
Three checked boxes do not guarantee approval. An officer may find that individual criteria are satisfied while concluding that the overall record does not establish eligibility.
What matters in the final merits determination
- Scope of recognition. Recognition at a national or international level, rather than merely local recognition.
- Independent evidence. Third-party evidence can carry more weight than the applicant's own assertions.
- Consistency. The criteria reinforce one another and tell a consistent story.
- Sustained recognition. Recognition should be sustained over time rather than rest on a single event.
- Context. Your record is assessed in the context of other professionals in your field.
What strengthens a case
- consider additional well-supported criteria where appropriate, rather than relying only on the minimum;
- focus on the quality of each piece of evidence, rather than merely its presence;
- obtain specific recommendation letters from independent experts;
- explain clearly why the achievements demonstrate the required level of ability.
What to do before filing
Review both each individual criterion and the record as a whole. We can help analyse your achievements, identify gaps and plan the evidence preparation.
Frequently asked questions
Is satisfying three of ten criteria enough?
Satisfying at least three criteria is one way to meet the initial evidentiary requirements, alongside the alternative of a qualifying major award. The officer then assesses whether the evidence as a whole establishes the required level of extraordinary ability.
What is an RFE?
A Request for Evidence is a USCIS request for additional information when the submitted record is insufficient to determine eligibility.
Need help with your case?
We review your achievements, identify strengths and gaps against the criteria, and suggest a plan. We work alongside your attorney.
→Request a consultation